I adored this book. I savoured every page, every word, every scene. It has almost single-handedly changed my view of Science Fiction YA (just a week after I proclaimed my distrust of the genre
- though I am not quite a convert yet).
These Broken Stars was not what I expected. In the spirit of the best science fiction, the novel incorporates socially-resonate themes elements into a classic tale. It is a story about social classes, corporate cover-ups and exploitation - but all in the context of a star-crossed, enemies-to-lovers romance.
In short: it is my definition of a good sci-fi book.
While reading this book, I posted on goodreads that I had found my YA version of Grimspace
(Ann Aguirre). I stick to that assessment. While the plots are nothing alike, both books have a certain je ne sais qoui
to them that makes me feel like they are in similar verses or perhaps have the same author (Spooner and Kaufman could be Aguirre's long-lost cousins? Well... it's a theory). Either way, I really can think of no higher compliment than this comparison. It's just as fierce, but with more party dresses.
On to a few specifics: These Broken Stars is a duo-narrative book, so the romance vibe is pretty apparent from the beginning. But I wouldn't say the relationship is the sole focus of this book. The characters are fighting to survive, fighting to stay sane... it's not until the end that they are fighting for each other. Not only did this focus make the relationship more realistic, it gave the authors a lot more page-time to focus on the plot... something I really appreciated.
Besides the realistic romance, I loved the culture in These Broken Stars. It felt almost like the monarchical, Victorian age - where fancy dress and poetry made headline news. But instead of a monarchy, this universe is run by corporations and militaries. I loved how both characters never really challenged this establishment, but both actively hated it. They don't start a Katniss-style revolution (and hey, their lives really aren't as bad), but they do stir the pot. I am hoping for a bit more "fight the system" spirit in the next book.
These Broken Stars is the first book in a trilogy, but the next books do not centre around these same characters. In a similar vein to Marissa Meyer's Lunar Chronicles
, each book is set in the same universe but focusses on different characters. I think I kind of love this trend for series, as I think it gives the author a wee bit more focus. Always a good thing!Bottom line?
These Broken Stars is a unique novel in the YA section. Romantic, political and with a side of high-tech science fiction goodness. I can't recommend it enough.Reviewed on Dead Book Darling